Trying to Make Sense of Nathan Phillips’ Saga

Trump Fans the Culture Wars Over an Encounter Between a Native Man and a Group of Teenagers, Calling Reports ‘Fake News.’ Whatever Happened to ‘Turn the Other Cheek’?

I’m trying to make sense of the senseless act of disrespect and intimidation that happened during Friday’s Indigenous Peoples March in Washington D.C.

By now, you’ve probably seen the video. It involves a group of mostly white teens from the all-male Covington Catholic High School in Kentucky and Nathan Phillips, a Native and a veteran. The youth were in D.C. for the anti-abortion March for Life rally; Phillips was there to take part in the Indigenous Peoples March. Both marches ended near the Lincoln Memorial.

As you see on the video, Phillips is surrounded by youth. He keeps playing his drum and singing. One youth in particular, junior Nick Sandmann, seems to block his path and smirk. The video created a national controversy and criticism of the school and the youth.

Screen capture from Washington Post video.

More details came out after the video’s release, according to a New York Times story. An initial confrontation took place between a small group of Black Hebrew Israelites who were “shouting racially combative comments at the Native Americans and the students.”

The Covington High students began responding to the taunts. According to an MPR story, “one of the students took off his shirt and the teens started to do a haka — a war dance of New Zealand’s indigenous Maori culture, made famous by the country’s national rugby team.”

Tensions were escalating.

Phillips said he intervened to diffuse the tensions, playing his drum and praying, according to a New York Times account, (According to an AP story, Phillips and Marcus Frejo, “a member of the Pawnee and Seminole tribes, said they felt the students were mocking the [haka] dance and walked over to intervene.”)

The end result was an iconic image with Sandmann and Phillips face to face. Sandmann issued a statement defending his actions. The youth said he didn’t antagonize or try to block Mr. Phillips, according to the New York Times report. He said. “I did not speak to him. I did not make any hand gestures or other aggressive moves.”

That fails to take into the broader context of Phillips being surrounded by youth. Some of Sandmann’s classmates  chanted “Build the wall” and “Go back to the reservation,” according to the AP account. From the video, some of the youth are doing the Tomahawk Chop and some seem to be treating the situation as amusement, smiling and taking photos. And several students, including Sandmann, wore MAGA hats, which have become synonymous with a racist world view.

[Update: President Trump tweeted in today in support for the high school students, according a Washington Post story: “Trump described Nick Sandmann, … and his fellow students as ‘symbols of Fake News and how evil it can be.’ Yet he also suggested that the Catholic teenagers could use the attention to ‘bring people together.’”

Acknowledging the Trauma

Phillips has been the focus of much of the news coverage, but the story is as much about the anger from black men that triggered the incident. Their anger shouldn’t be surprising. But people who don’t know the history of slavery, Jim Crow, lynchings, and redlining — and their present day manifestations of mass incarceration of black men and the incredible wealth disparities between blacks and whites — won’t hear the truth and trauma behind that anger. Anger is hard to hear.

Consider this. How many of us have gotten angry and cursed when someone cuts us off in traffic? How much angrier would we be if someone cut us and our family off from opportunity for generations?

It’s hard to blame the youth for reacting to the anger (though you do wonder where the adult leadership was.) The youth’s actions weren’t thought out. In such tense situations, we all pretty much run on autopilot, playing out our habits. These youth are acting out in ways they absorb in their families, community and school.

I’m not saying they should have engaged in dialogue. Sometimes the best thing we can do is not get defensive, turn the other cheek, and simply walk away. Sometimes we are called to engage. That’s what Phillips did. He saw a stressful situation and took the risk of walking in alone and giving his best, more prayerful effort, at calming things down.

You’d hope the Covington High youth, their school, and their community would learn from this experience, that we all could learn from this experience. This is America’s story. We all need to talk about it. We all need to learn. We all need to be transformed. It’s a painful path, but it’s our only hope.

2 thoughts on “Trying to Make Sense of Nathan Phillips’ Saga

  1. The “innocence” of the Covington boys is further contradicted by at least 2 videos of their actions along the parade route. If I were a part of the school’s administration, I’d have serious questions for the supervisors/chaperones who allowed them to wear MAGA hats to politically charged events and didn’t stop them from the jeering and insensitive actions.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s